By Carl Weiner
The fundamental purpose of homeowners’ associations and condominium associations is the operation, maintenance, repair and replacement of the association’s common elements. Decisions about ongoing operation, maintenance, repair and upgrade of common elements are made by the association’s board. Both the Pennsylvania Uniform Condominium Act and Pennsylvania Uniform Planned Community Act give association boards broad discretion to determine the appropriate manner of maintaining and improving common elements.
Understanding Association Budgets and Reserve Funding
The association, through the board, annually adopts a budget to determine the anticipated expense of operating and maintaining common elements of the association in the coming year. However, the board must consider not only the current needs of the association’s common elements but must also anticipate future costs of replacing or improving the association’s common elements. The current expenses anticipated in the coming year are considered to be operating expenses and the future repair and replacement costs related to the common elements are considered to be capital expenditures. A well-run association should have a substantial reserve fund in place to cover anticipated future capital expenses. These expenses may cover a wide variety of improvements depending on the nature of the development, such as road paving, sidewalk and curb replacement, roof replacement, elevator repair and replacement, sewer and water lateral replacements, plumbing system upgrades, HVAC system upgrades and building exterior maintenance. The list of structural elements which must be maintained by an association is as varied as the types of thousands of associations existing in Pennsylvania.
Given the many different forms of housing developments and the wide variety of capital improvements that associations are designated to implement, there is no specific legal requirement that establishes a definitive test for the appropriate level of reserves maintained by an association. Under the provisions of the Pennsylvania Uniform Condominium Act and Uniform Planned Community Act, as well as under the precedent established by Pennsylvania case law, the guiding principle for establishing the required level of reserves is the fiduciary duty of the association board to act in the best interest of all members of the association. The board must act in the best interest of the association’s short-term and long-term needs and make its decisions regarding the association’s expenses in the context of the business judgment rule. The business judgment rule essentially provides that boards are to spend the association’s money in a manner that a typical business would apply in deciding to spend its money by taking into account reasonable sources of income, competing expenses, appropriate allocation of resources and the needs of various groups of owners within the association.
Fannie Mae's Role in Condominium Reserve Funding
While there are no specific statutory requirements relating to reserve studies, the Federal National Mortgage Association, otherwise known as Fannie Mae, establishes guidelines which set important benchmarks for associations, particularly condominium associations. Fannie Mae was established as part of the New Deal in 1938 to buy mortgages from commercial banks and other lenders in order to promote home lending. In that role, the agency regulates standards that lenders must adhere to in lending funds to buyers for the purchase of homes in different types of developments. Under the applicable Fannie Mae regulations, lenders may issue loans to homes in condominium developments only if the condominium project has been prequalified. There are a number of qualifications that condominium associations must meet in order to be eligible for Fannie Mae loans. Examples include requiring common elements to be consistent with the nature of the project, requiring unit owners to have the sole interest and right to use common elements, requiring the developer to divest all ownership interest in the common elements and prohibiting any lease arrangement between the association and any third party regarding common elements. As to the operation of associations, Fannie Mae requires that no more than fifteen (15%) percent of the total units in an association may be delinquent in payment of assessments by sixty (60) days or more.
Fannie Mae has recently focused extensively on the requirements for reserve funding to provide assurances that sufficient funds are in place for future maintenance, operation, repair and replacement of common elements. Following the infamous June 2021 collapse of the Champlain Towers Condominium Building in Surfside, Florida, in which ninety-eight people died, it was determined that the building collapsed, in part, due to the failure of its association to commit the funding necessary for the inspection and repair of structural elements of the building which had been deteriorating for years.
Fannie Mae requires that each association obtain a common element reserve study every three years to determine the condition of structural components of the common elements. That reserve study should be done by a qualified engineering firm which examines the current condition of the condominium common elements and determines the timetable in which future expenses in upgrading common elements are reasonably anticipated and the anticipated cost of those expenses. The reserve studies prepared by engineering consultants provide a basis for the board to fulfill its fiduciary responsibility to the association by using good business judgment in establishing appropriate funding to account for the future repairs, replacement and upgrade of various structural components of the common elements.
What the New Requirements Mean for 2027 Association Budgets
Current regulations provide that ten (10%) percent of the annual association budget income is to be allocated to fund the association reserve accounts. However, in March 2026, Fannie Mae issued Lender Letter LL-2026-03, which updated its capital reserve requirements effective in 2027. All associations preparing their 2027 budgets need to be aware that Fannie Mae regulations now provide that as of January 4, 2027, the portion of the condominium association budget which is specifically allocated for funding reserve accounts must be increased from ten (10%) percent to fifteen (15%) percent of the annual budget assessment income. This requirement is subject to two limited exceptions:
(a) The reserve study must be no more than three years old; and
(b) The amount of funding in the association’s actual reserves must be greater than the baseline funding recommended by the reserve study.
Otherwise, associations are going to have to kick up their contributions to the association’s reserve funds. An association budget established for 2026 which took into account anticipated operating expenses in 2026 and a ten (10%) percent set-aside for the reserve fund must now account for reasonably expected increases in costs of operating expenses for 2027 and, in addition, provide for a five (5%) percent increase in reserve funding. Further, since the income level of the association is likely to be increased in anticipation of increased capital expenditures, not only is the percentage required to be increased but the baseline income level on which the reserve percentage is based will also be increased. Many condominium unit owners may reasonably expect to pay greater assessments in 2027 based on these factors unless the association can find ways of cutting expenses without jeopardizing proper operation and maintenance of the common elements, both in the short term in 2027 as well as in the future. Association boards cannot, in the best interest of the association, fulfill their fiduciary duty by randomly cutting expenses while at the same time unreasonably deferring necessary expenditures.
The lesson learned from the Champlain Towers collapse and the situation that Fannie Mae is trying to prevent is that while it is often difficult to increase assessments and impose those increases on unit owners with a potentially limited income, the concept of kicking the can down the road with respect to necessary association maintenance is, in the end, likely to create far worse consequences.
With new reserve funding requirements on the horizon, now is the time for condominium association boards to review their budgets, assess their reserve funding strategies, and understand their fiduciary responsibilities. The attorneys at HRMM&L have extensive experience advising condominium and homeowners’ associations on governance, budgeting, and compliance matters. Contact HRMM&L today to discuss how these changes may affect your association and how proactive planning can help protect your community’s financial future.